The design calculations for members subject to fluctuating loads with the same factor of safety, yield the most conservative estimates when using
A. Gerber relation
B. Soderberg relation
C. Goodman relation
D. None of these
Answer: Option B
Solution (By Examveda Team)
When designing machine components under fluctuating or alternating loads, it is essential to account for fatigue failure.Different failure theories or criteria are used to estimate the safety of such components, with varying levels of conservativeness.
Gerber relation uses a parabolic curve and is less conservative, allowing for higher allowable stresses.
Goodman relation is linear and more conservative than Gerber but less than Soderberg.
Soderberg relation is the most conservative. It uses the yield strength instead of the ultimate strength for comparison and assumes a linear relation. This provides the lowest permissible stress, making it the safest design for fluctuating loads when using the same factor of safety.
Therefore, using the Soderberg relation yields the most conservative estimates for fluctuating loads.
Correct Answer: Option B: Soderberg relation
Join The Discussion
Comments (5)
Related Questions on Machine Design
A cotter joint is used to connect two __________ rods.
A. Co-axial
B. Perpendicular
C. Parallel
D. None of these
The rated life of a bearing varies
A. Directly as load
B. Inversely as square of load
C. Inversely as cube of load
D. Inversely as fourth power of load
The bending stress in a curved beam is
A. Zero at the centroidal axis
B. Zero at the point other than centroidal axis
C. Maximum at the neutral axis
D. None of these
The centre to centre distance between two consecutive rivets in a row, is called
A. Margin
B. Pitch
C. Back pitch
D. Diagonal pitch

B And is correct in khurmi
Soderberg is most conservative at yield point
the answer must be soderberg please correct it exam veda
Soderberg relation
Yes, most conservative is Soderberg only.