Examveda

Which of the following gives the work required for size reduction of coal to -200 mesh in a ball mill most accurately ?

A. Rittinger's law

B. Kick's law

C. Bond's law

D. None of these

Answer: Option A


This Question Belongs to Chemical Engineering >> Mechanical Operations

Join The Discussion

Comments (2)

  1. Atanu Chatterjee
    Atanu Chatterjee:
    6 months ago

    The correct answer is:

    C. Bond's law

    Explanation:
    When dealing with intermediate particle size reduction, especially in the range of 100 mesh to 325 mesh (like -200 mesh), Bond's law provides the most accurate estimation of the energy required.

    Here's a quick comparison of the laws:

    Rittinger’s Law: Best for fine grinding (very small particles); assumes energy is proportional to new surface area created.

    Kick’s Law: Best for coarse size reduction; assumes energy is proportional to volume reduction.

    Bond’s Law: Most accurate for intermediate size reduction, such as coal to -200 mesh; it uses a work index and considers the square root of particle sizes.

    So, for coal ground to -200 mesh in a ball mill, Bond's law is the most suitable.
    ✅ Correct Answer: C. Bond's law

  2. Dk Bose
    Dk Bose:
    5 years ago

    200 mesh is very small and when the particle diameter is very less Rittinger's law (n=2) is useful

Related Questions on Mechanical Operations