Manna asked Rohan, "Have you sat in a trolley bus before ?"
A. Manna asked Rohan had he sat in a trolley bus earlier.
B. Manna asked Rohan had he sat in a trolley bus before.
C. Manna asked Rohan if he sat on a trolley bus before.
D. Manna asked Rohan if he has ever sat in a trolley bus.
Answer: Option D
Solution (By Examveda Team)
In direct speech, the question is: "Have you sat in a trolley bus before?"To convert it into indirect speech, we use the reporting verb "asked" followed by the reporting clause "if" or "whether" and the appropriate tense. In this case, the tense remains the same as the original question, so "have" becomes "has" in the indirect speech because it's referring to the present perfect tense.
Therefore, the correct conversion is: "Manna asked Rohan if he has ever sat in a trolley bus."
This Question Belongs to Competitive English >> Direct And Indirect Speech
This is wrong answer. As per rules of narrations, Present Perfect Tense changes into Past Perfect Tense while making indirect speech. Kindly rectify this blunder.
Wrong answer.
Please update the answer option and add or replace the wrong answer choice with "Manna asked Rohan wheater he had sat in a trolley bus earlier."
Please remove the mistake for newcomers
wrong options...
Why it will be the option number A, I couldn't understand. So, Please clarify me.
I think it will be:-
Manna asked Rohan wheater he had sat in a trolley bus earlier.
All options are wrong.
The right answer is Manna asked Rohan if he had sat in a trolley bus before.
Mana asked rohan if he had sat in trolly bus before.
The answer is wrong
Correct
Manna asked Rohan if he had sat in a trolley bus earlier
See the uses of conditional sentences u will get it
Answer should be........
Manna asked rohan if he had sat in trolly bus before
In this question, why we doesn't use "If". It is a Interrogative sentence. and It can be answer in Yes/No format. Please explain
in this sentence the part of speech is in interrogative mode and also started with "have", so according to the rule when we changed the sentence into indirect speech than we replaced the helping verb and we used "if/whether" instead of is/am/are/has/have/etc. and after it we right the sentence in assertive mode.